Facebook's fiasco: 5 less-than-obvious losers

While Morgan Stanley and the Nasdaq face lawsuits from irate investors, they aren't the only ones faced with fallout from the IPO flop.

By The Fiscal Times Jun 1, 2012 10:29AM
The Fiscal Times

By Suzanne McGee

Let's be blunt. The Facebook (FB) IPO wasn't just egg on the face of the company, its underwriters and the Nasdaq Stock Market; it was an omelet of record-breaking proportions. But while Morgan Stanley (MS) and the exchange face lawsuits from irate investors and individuals who had to wait hours to be told they owned Facebook shares and that they had bought it at prices that may not be seen again for months, at least, these folks aren't the only losers. In fact, throughout the entire IPO process, it's hard to find any winners.

As with any market shakeup or crisis, the ripples from Facebook's bungled IPO stretch far and wide. Here is a quick snapshot of some of the less self-evident losers from this particular fiasco.

Wall Street trading firms
One after another, these folks are filing claims with Nasdaq OMX Group (NDAQ) for trading losses incurred as a result of the mayhem surrounding the first day of trading in Facebook shares.


Nasdaq previously said it hopes to keep payouts under $13 million, but Knight Capital Group (KCG) alone has claimed it lost $30 million and Tom Joyce, the company's CEO, estimated early on that total losses may top $100 million.


The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority likely will oversee the arbitration process with Knight, Fidelity Securities ($30 million to $35 million), E-Trade Financial, UBS (UBS) ($30 million), Citigroup (C) ($20 million) and Citadel Securities ($30 million plus) and others.


Even if many of those claims prove ill founded, the payout is almost certain to be closer to $100 million than $13 million. True, it's likely that nobody is crying for Wall Street traders, but at a time when investment banks are battling to boost profitability, any dent in profits is likely to cost some folks their jobs as a new wave of cost-cutting begins -- and odds are it won't be the jobs of those involved in the Facebook IPO that vanish.

Facebook Insiders
Early investors in Facebook like venture firm Accel Partners have already made a lot of money by backing Mark Zuckerberg's brainchild. And many of them have already lightened up their holdings of Facebook stock, selling into the IPO or unloading shares privately in the months before the offering was announced.


That's lucky, because although the lockup prohibiting them from selling into the market will expire in part as early as August, the odds are that they won't be able to capture anything close to the IPO price.


It's clear that aftermarket demand for Facebook stock is anemic at best, and in the absence of a blowout second-quarter earnings announcement, there's no sign of any news that will displace the big black mark that the IPO left on the stock's reputation among investors. That, in turn, means that any insider selling on the expiry of the lockups in August and toward Thanksgiving may well be met with more waves of selling.


If they do sell, those insiders will still make bucketloads of money -- but not nearly as much as they and their own investors had counted on. It's a bit like picking five of the six numbers in the lottery correctly, and then missing the sixth one by only a single digit.

Zynga
It was nice while it lasted… The game developer behind Farmville relies on Facebook for 92% of its revenue, as it just revealed in its quarterly filing with the SEC. The company went public last year at $10 a share, and rapidly saw its stock price sink below that IPO price.


For a brief moment in time, it seemed as if the Facebook buzz might provide a jolt of energy to the beleaguered Zynga (ZNGA) shares, as they surged 10% in the days leading up the Facebook IPO to trade as high as $8.88. Flash forward two weeks, and they're back down, languishing at a mere $5.87 as of Wednesday's close.


The snapback to reality from pre-IPO hype was even more brutal for Zynga than for Facebook itself. After all, Facebook users don't have to pay to play games -- they can use the site for myriad other purposes.


Unsurprisingly, Mark Pincus, the CEO of Zynga, told a California technology conference Wednesday that he's actively exploring alternatives to Facebook, ranging from its own platform to mobile software platforms based on Google's (GOOG) Android and other operating systems.


For now, however, the company's fate -- and its stock price -- seem inextricably linked to Facebook, which is anything but a comfortable position right now.

The IPO Market
Facebook was supposed to have coattails, wasn't it? Certainly, the buzz among investment bankers in the run-up to the IPO was that the deal would be a slam-dunk success, help investors put to one side their anxiety about the storm clouds circling in Europe and focus instead on the upside potential for high-growth startups. Whoops.


Instead, Kayak Software Corp. is reported to have decided to delay its own IPO, postponing a roadshow that should have started last week; similarly, Russia's largest social networking company, VKontakte, put a hold on its own IPO after Facebook's face plant dampened investor enthusiasm for the sector as a whole. And Graff Diamonds was set to go public in Hong Kong but pulled the offering just a day before it was supposed to price.


Given that investors now appear to be firmly back in the "risk off" camp, with macroeconomic anxieties preoccupying them, it may take those deals months to get back on track. Certainly, it's unlikely that they'll be ready to try again until after the market has digested whatever happens during June's elections in Greece.

Mark Zuckerberg
Given that Facebook's founder showed up to roadshow events wearing a hoodie, it's unlikely that he cares much about losing a billion dollars or more from his net worth, but since his company went public, Zuckerberg has fallen off the list of the world's 40 wealthiest people.


As of Wednesday, his net worth (based on the value of his stake in Facebook) had fallen to around $14 billion from $19.1 billion on the day of the IPO. That's still enough to ensure that he, his new wife and their pooch, Beast, will live in comfort for the rest of their days, and enough to ensure he'll be wooed for philanthropic donations from pretty much every group worldwide. And it's also safe to say that, basking in newlywed bliss, he probably isn't brooding too much about those stray billions just yet. But it will serve as a sharp reminder that Facebook now has a lot to prove to its new shareholders, and it's up to Zuckerberg to find a way to deliver the outsize growth implied in the premium IPO price.

Admittedly, few of those who have suffered from the Facebook fiasco are those that we should stay up late at nights worrying about. Even the individual investors who raced to buy Facebook stock in hopes of flipping it at a profit within a few hours -- while they may get our compassion for losses they can't really afford -- probably are paying the price for succumbing to the temptation to gamble on what they believed, falsely, to be a sure thing.


As for the other businesses and the Facebook insiders -- well, this is the kinda stuff they warn you about in business classes. Collateral damage of any kind is never pretty, but in this case, at least, it's easy to understand what happened and why -- and to learn from the debacle.

Suzanne McGee is a columnist at The Fiscal Times. Subscribe to The Fiscal Times' FREE newsletter.

More from The Fiscal Times

3Comments
Jun 1, 2012 11:25AM
avatar

As I said several weeks ago, Facebook was just another example of the same kind of ridiculous mind-set as the dot-com bubble of a few years ago.  Eveyone gets excited thinking they have found gold, but it usually turns out to be fools gold. 

 

That is NOT what the stock market was developed for!  It was developed for people to trade stocks of companies that make things or do something of value so that the investors can participate in those earnings and collect DIVIDENDS!  Too many people are out to make a quick killing in a sky rocketing stock and aren't content to collect their dividends and let the power of compound interest (dividends) work for them.

Jun 1, 2012 11:10AM
avatar
What did we learn? The stock market is rigged.
Jun 1, 2012 11:39AM
avatar

Meanwhile, Morgan Stanley’s CEO was on TV this morning championing his company’s performance and Facebook. I saw this interview coming like a train down the track. I’ve been calling for it for ten days now, but, I knew it wouldn’t come until there was an upward pop in the Facebook stock price. That would be the cue for the chief salesman in charge to finally get out and spew a load of BS about what has transpired and try drumming up more interest in the stock from the buy side. Make hay while the sun shines as they say. I wouldn’t be surprised if Morgan Stanley was the one who made the sun shine by buying up share prices late yesterday afternoon on low volume. Nothing like a self-fulfilling prophecy to make you look good on camera, even if it does require a little stock price manipulation. And where is he today, or any of the other dozens of underwriters and Facebook insiders now that the stock price has fallen back 5% again? Probably back in his bunker with the rest, riding out the storm they created, and working on their next fairy tale story to sell to their Zucker clients when the stock price pops up again from $20 to $21. What a sham.

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

DATA PROVIDERS

Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.

STOCK SCOUTER

StockScouter rates stocks from 1 to 10, with 10 being the best, using a system of advanced mathematics to determine a stock's expected risk and return. Ratings are displayed on a bell curve, meaning there will be fewer ratings of 1 and 10 and far more of 4 through 7.

123
123 rated 1
262
262 rated 2
480
480 rated 3
651
651 rated 4
649
649 rated 5
629
629 rated 6
616
616 rated 7
496
496 rated 8
346
346 rated 9
111
111 rated 10
12345678910

Top Picks

SYMBOLNAMERATING
EXCEXELON CORPORATION9
TAT&T Inc9
VZVERIZON COMMUNICATIONS8
CTLCENTURYLINK Inc8
AAPLAPPLE Inc10
More

VIDEO ON MSN MONEY

ABOUT

Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.

Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.

Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.