Europe won't allow history to repeat itself
In a region where Weimar inflation and German deflation led to social unrest and the rise of Hitler, peace and stability are more important than triple-A credit ratings.
In other words, there truly is no plan big enough and no entity large enough to rescue banks from themselves. The European banks, unlike the American ones, are so huge and so intertwined with the fortunes of sovereign debt that anyone who even thinks there could be a solution that isn't catastrophic is regarded as a lightweight.
After all, the banks collectively are three times as large as the gross domestic product of Europe, compared with only about 70% for ours, and that may be understating the size of the European entities. Even if China, the United States and the IMF got involved, there wouldn't be enough money to bail them out.
Of course, they could be nationalized, but that would mean the backstop countries would all have their credit ratings downgraded, and those are meant to be sacrosanct.
Post continues below:
I have no doubt that the bearish commentators and analysts are smarter than I'll ever be. I have no doubt that they are right about the scale and size of the issue.
But I wonder if they understand the history of the continent. I wonder if they don't overstate the need for these countries to protect their AAA ratings, and if they should be more focused on the idea that these European countries are all about having peace in the end and not descending into the brutal wars that seem like they happened just yesterday.
In the end, they will sacrifice their AAA ratings and their standards of living and start over if they have to. So the idea that there is no solution other than to bring the world down is not going to hold water.
Of course, the rap is also that they have to bring down the world with them, that there is no way we won't have a worse recession than in 2008-09. And the understanding among bearish traders, I think, is that even the pain of the Depression will be exceeded this time.
- The 2 most important earnings reports this week
- Caterpillar's earnings show no recession on the way
- 5 reasons to buy American Express now
Again, I think that represents a keen misunderstanding of history. No, the problem can't be cordoned. But yes, any recession that brought down GM (GM), Merrill, Fannie and Freddie, Wachovia, Washington Mutual, Bear Stearns, Lehman and AIG (AIG) -- include Citigroup (C) if you want -- is one that has left little in its wake except some much stronger institutions. And there is another tier of banks, notably of the BB&T (BBT) and U.S. Bancorp (USB) variety, that stand ready to replace the current ones if they fail.
I understand the desire to bet against copper and aluminum off this imminent European collapse. I do not understand how they can't also be short oil. I do not understand how they think there can never be a way out of anything.
I also do not understand how they can't see that these countries experienced the rise of Hitler and Stalin, and you have to concede that they must have learned something about how economics can lead to social unrest and dictatorships and genocide, so a solution will have to leave the fabric intact -- even if the fabric is more polyester than cotton when we are through with this era.
Just some thoughts on why these markets may be more resilient than people think. Not just because Honeywell (HON) has seen no slowdown and McDonald's (MCD) has seen an acceleration but because history says that Weimar inflation and German deflation breed Nazi Germany. So maybe, just maybe, it is worth sacrificing a triple-A rating to keep history from repeating itself.
At the time of publication, Cramer was long USB.
Jimmy Boy how do come up with this crap? Please try to contain yourself, you are sounding more and more like the towns
idiot every day.
This extreme worst case thinking will really only lead to kick the can solutions that will cause more harm long term than good in the short term.
That being said, man are the US markets loving earnings and Euro possibilities of free money.
In the end, they will sacrifice their AAA ratings and their standards of living and start over if they have to.
Excuse me? Isn't that the same as the austerity measures in Greece right now. How is lowering the standard of living throughout Europe going to guarantee social stability? Clearly it won't. You'll get what you have in Greece right now. The EU is damned if they do and damned if they don't. Moreover , there's a good possibility that if they massively leverage themselves to find the funding for the bailout plan it will still fail .
One issue not addressed in this article however, is how financially interconnected the European banks are to the American ones. Some of that TARP money the FED got went directly to the European banks. Both the American and European banks are heavily leveraged in the derivative market. If the EU and the Euro collapse it will hit the U.S. banks and the U.S. dollar as well. The fate of the U.S. and the global economy hinges on just how well the EU manages the financial meltdown that is about to happen. I wish had a solution that didn't cause financial pain and suffering, but I can't think of one. I hope Mr. Cramer is right and the people running the EU have this under control. I'm not going to trust any of this wishful thinking however, until I see a concrete financial plan from Europe on how they plan to do this.
germany shouldn't help anyone but germany
geemany shouldn't be lumped with the rest of europe
germany is a world leader in education
germany does't have people going broke because they get sick
germany has ceo's making 40 times the average worker's salary where we have them making 460 times the averag worker,s salary
germany has the average worker making 20% more than our average worker
germany wishes the berlin wall would be rebuilt only twice as high this time
germany is the BEER capital of the world
america could learn from germany..............but they won't
the shyster continues his babble,if you are new to investing don't be
fooled.......how can his colleagues on cnbc stand his mouth....he doesn't listen to them
and is chomping at the bit to let out his diarreah all over the set ......this guy
must really have the goods on somebody to get so much air time while contributing
absolutely nothing of value.....and speaking like he knows about europe is just plain wrong
PUT THIS CROOK IN JAIL
we are so far behind europe AND asia that we can't see their tail pipes
it is america that has been downgraded and is in decline
look at our world rank in healthcare and education
as the 99% movement shows;people are tired of super rich getting richer off the backs of slave labor wages
and tying health care to whether or not some one has a job is just inane
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.