Zynga wants its stock back
As it heads to a potentially blockbuster IPO, the online gaming company is reportedly asking some employees to surrender some shares.
The company regrets giving employees so many stock grants in its early days, according to a report in The Wall Street Journal. So it's telling some workers to give back some shares -- or get fired.
Zynga executives were concerned about creating a "Google chef" situation, the Journal reported. They were referring to the chef who joined Google (GOOG) in the early days and walked away with $20 million after the company went public.
Zynga makes the popular "Farmville" and "Mafia Wars" games, and could be looking at a valuation of $20 billion if its IPO goes well. Employees are sitting on a lot of money. In fact, some of them were sitting on as much as $200 million each, said one person close to the company, according to the Journal.
Chief executive Mark Pincus reportedly developed a hit list of employees whose work he thought didn't justify the large blocks of restricted shares they received when they were hired, according to the Journal.
Most of those aware of Zynga's demands for the return of stock said the effort was designed to replenish the pool of shares that could be awarded to attract new talent. One person called the effort part of Mr. Pincus's strategy to continually assess employees and create a meritocracy where the biggest rewards would go to biggest contributors, and nobody could just "rest and vest."
I can see where Pincus is going with this. It's not unusual for some Silicon Valley workers to get a little flaky if they're expecting a huge IPO paycheck. Facebook and other companies have seen early employees quit altogether -- taking their stock grants with them, of course.
Many employees have sold those grants on the secondary market, making a pretty penny long before an IPO becomes reality.
But a promise is a promise -- particularly when it's written into an employment contract. Some Zynga employees have reportedly hired attorneys to deal with the company's demands.
The article is making Zynga look pretty bad. The company didn't exactly deny the report, but said it was based on hearsay and innuendo and "paints our meritocracy in a false and skewed light." Here's Pincus in a memo obtained by Fortune:
Being a meritocracy is one of our core values and it's on our walls. We believe that every employee deserves the same opportunity to lead. Its not about where or when you enter zynga its how far you can grow. This is what our culture of leveling up is all about and its one of our coolest features.
Commenters on Twitter were fired up about the issue, calling the company wrong, sickening and a scumbag.
Fortune's Dan Primack saw it differently, suggesting that Zynga wanted to demote under-performing employees and cut their compensation by reducing the number of unvested options:
But this isn't Major League Baseball, where the Boston Red Sox are stuck paying Carl Crawford $20 million per year even if he proves no better than a backup. It's a non-unionized startup, where the CEO is well within his rights to simply fire an under-performing employee (and recover unvested options). In fact, that's what happens at most companies. The difference at Zynga is that Pincus seems intent on retaining talent, even if that talent either didn't live up to initial expectations or didn't adequately match up to the changing needs of a fast-growing company.
So an "underperforming" CEO who has a "contract" gets to walk away with millions after he bankrupts a company and hundreds, even thousands of people lose their livelihoods, but "contracts" with "underperforming" employees can be negated at the whims of one person?
Merely because he granted too many stock options in early contracts with employee's?
Maybe they should make EVERY employee (including the CEO) give back 1% of the shares they own?....
What was the name of this pig at the trough, again? Oh yeah, got it now. Mark PIMP-US. What a sorry excuse for a capitalist.
Washington sucks for allowing this BS to go unchecked. Likewise, corporate American leadership members that participate in and/or condone this type of activity swallow.
MORE ON MSN MONEY
Copyright © 2013 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Quotes are real-time for NASDAQ, NYSE and AMEX. See delay times for other exchanges.
All hail the bull market, which ended the week with a big rally. But it also is starting to look a little like 1987, which suffered an epic blow-out.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.