A budget iPhone is a bad idea
Remember what happened when Dell made a similar move?
It's a cautionary tale for Apple (AAPL), whose position today is uncomfortably similar to Dell's eight years ago. The company is larger and more profitable than ever, just coming off the best quarter in its history, while the stock is down 35% since September 2012 on worries over market share.
But would this address the company’s problems? What, after all, is wrong with Apple? I offered my take several months ago, arguing that the marriage between Apple's IOS operating system and its handheld devices -- the iPad and iPhone -- essentially guarantees a minority share for the company's products. The Android ecosystem offers a wider range of hardware and more flexibility in price points, and by addressing a larger market it attracts more attention from software developers. Eventually, Droid will benefit from the same software-driven momentum that made Microsoft's (MSFT) Windows so unstoppable in personal computers. (Microsoft owns and publishes Top Stocks, an MSN Money site.) In the tech world, hardware makers come and go, but platforms are forever. Apple is, and always has been, a hardware company.
A budget iPhone won't change this. Cheap devices have never been Apple's strength, and the company's minimalist approach to its product catalogue -- selling fewer devices, that don't compete with each other -- is the result of a lesson learned in the '90s, when a confused lineup was one of several issues that nearly brought Apple to bankruptcy. On his return in 1997, Steve Jobs said that the era of "competition between Apple and Microsoft is over," and he refocused the company towards the innovative premium products it has proven to be so good at. Few today would question that decision.
It would be a mistake for Apple to chase Google, and an even bigger mistake for investors to believe that the company can compete with Android on market share. The remarkable thing isn't that Apple is losing ground, but that for a few years it was able -- with a single, high-end product -- to dominate the industry so completely. A lower-cost iPhone would sacrifice margins for a questionable growth, and it would dilute the one asset that truly makes Apple different: the loyalty of its customers.
Several different surveys show that iPhone users are largely content with Apple, and less likely than Droid users to make a switch. There are two factors at work here. First, leaving the iPhone means abandoning iOS, and changing operating systems can be a difficult and expensive process. This tends to limit any bleeding of current customers, which explains why, in all the years of competition between Macs and PCs, the battle lines remained relatively constant.
Second, Apple's holistic approach generally results in a smoother experience; its operating system is simpler to use and less vulnerable to malware. This comfortable environment is not without its limitations, but by and large, people are satisfied with it.
Given that the company's customer base is unlikely to exit en masse, the lack of a budget iPhone constitutes an enormous advantage; it guarantees that each of these customers pays a premium price. A low-cost device might win over some Android users, and stave off competition from Samsung (SSNLF), but it will also cannibalize Apple's existing customers, who won't have to switch platforms to take advantage of it. While a cheaper handset may grab share in the developing world, it would mean devaluing the iPhone's core markets -- U.S. and Europe -- in an attempt to grab new ones.
Apple should continue to do what it has always done: sell high-quality products. The company may no longer be the darling of Wall Street, but its position is more secure than investors seem to think; it may lose share, but it's unlikely to lose customers. So long as Apple can pump out $30 billion/year in cash, its stock will provide a compelling value. Growth, on the other hand, will have to come from innovation in new markets, and not from chasing old ones.
More from Minyanville
- US Tech Overseas: eBay Expands in India; Zynga Plays Poker, Facebook Joke Causes Stir in China
- The Basics on Bitcoin: 11 Things to Know About This Suddenly 'Hot' Digital Currency
- Could a New BlackBerry Tablet Be More Than Just an April Fools' Joke?
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
The stock rises 9% after the company reveals strong second-quarter results.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.