Ford or General Motors: Which is the better value?

In a rising auto market, both hold great appeal, but investors should roll with the stronger operator.

By StreetAuthority Apr 18, 2013 3:46PM

Car salesman showing couple new silver hatchback in car showroom copyright Juice Images, Cultura, Getty ImagesBy David Sterman                                                   


While watching sports on TV last weekend, I saw dozens of car commercials. It's understandable why automakers are spending so heavily on ads these days: Put simply, business is good.


An industry that struggled to sell more than 10 million vehicles in North America in 2009 continues to strengthen: 15 million vehicles may find a home this year, judging by March sales data. That figure could actually hit 15.7 million, which would be less than 10% below the all-time highs set during the past decade, according to Edmunds.com.


Yet, as I've noted in many columns about automakers, you simply can't compare these companies' recent performance with the past decade. As Goldman Sachs' analysts noted in an April 15 report, "Detroit has come back from the depths of the crisis stronger and more profitable than ever."


In fact, the auto industry is so much stronger now, in so many respects, that an investment in almost any automaker or auto parts supplier makes a great deal of sense -- especially in light of the fact that their valuations discount the strides they've made.


About a month ago on the Street Authority, I pointed out the hidden value in auto parts suppliers, and I remain especially keen on the automakers themselves. If you have a multi-year time frame, you stand to generate robust returns with either Ford (F) or General Motors Co. (GM).


Still, if you had to choose just one, which one would it be?


I did a similar analysis on the Street Authority back in August 2011 and gave a slight edge to Ford. Since then, Ford and GM have posted gains of 25% and 10%, respectively, compared with a 30.5% gain for the S&P 500.


To my thinking, the fact that both automakers have lagged behind the S&P 500 since then isn't a sign of trouble -- it means they hold even greater value, relative to the rest of the market, than they did back then.


Although Ford emerged from the recession as the more impressive operator, GM is starting to get its game together as well. The company's various vehicle lines are in the midst of a refresh -- including a new Corvette, upgraded Cadillac sedans and a new full-size pickup -- which is helping to boost pricing and margins. In fact, fully 33% of GM's vehicles will be upgraded in the next 12 months, which is the highest percentage in the industry, according to UBS.


GM still holds 17% of the North American car and truck market thus far in 2013, compared with a 16% share for Ford. GM also has a somewhat stronger presence in foreign markets outside of Europe, including the all-important Chinese market. Ford is building seven manufacturing plants across Asia to help build market share in that region, but the benefits of that investment are probably several years away.


Ford's areas of relative strength:


  • A tighter line on inventories at dealer locations, which enables it to reduce the size of discounts and incentives it must provide to move the metal. (GM provided $3,400 in discounts per vehicle in March, compared with $2,800 for Ford, according to TrueCar.com.)
  • A path to sharply reduced losses in the troubled European market: Ford could reach a break-even point in that market by next year, possibly a year ahead of GM. GM's decision to invest in France's Peugeot has not been well-received by analysts, as it may take management attention away from the need to shrink GM's European expense base.
  • Ford has the industry's most efficient use of engines, suspensions, interiors and other equipment that is shared across vehicle lineups.
  • Ford will embark on an aggressive product refresh in 2014 and 2015, after GM's big new vehicle push slows down.


Let's compare the key financial metrics:




The first lines you should note are two measures of organizational efficiency. In terms of earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) margins and return on invested capital, Ford remains the far stronger player.


And while GM sports a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio and EBITDA ratio that are lower than Ford's, it has trailed badly in terms of free cash flow. That's why Ford is now paying a dividend and is expected to boost it at a rapid clip, while GM is not yet doing so. Ford has thus far used its prodigious free cash flow to reduce its debt load by roughly $20 billion during the past few years.


Will GM eventually focus on dividends and share buybacks? With "several years of strong cash flow ahead, there is excess liquidity that we expect will ultimately make its way to shareholders," said Goldman's analysts.


To be sure, GM's $21 billion net cash position is more impressive than Ford's $10 billion. But Ford's pension plan is in far healthier shape, and GM will likely have to drain away a sizable chunk of its current cash to shore up its pension.


Risks to Consider: If Ford and GM can't sharply reduce their losses in Europe, both firms will remain out of favor. Both automakers have made huge bets on China and need its economy to continue expanding.


Action to Take: GM is in better shape than you might think. The current management team is making many smart moves, and were it not for Ford's even more impressive turnaround, GM would be garnering more buzz. Still, Ford continues to carry the torch in this industry with its superior set of management decisions. Although shares of GM may look like a slightly better value, it's wise to stay with Ford, the industry's pacesetter.


David Sterman does not personally hold positions in any securities mentioned in this article. 


More from StreetAuthority

MSN Money on Twitter and Facebook

Like us on Facebook: MSN Money and Top Stocks

Follow us on Twitter: @msn_money and @topstocksmsn


Tags: FGM
103Comments
Apr 18, 2013 5:24PM
avatar

Considering that Ford does NOT have my money tied up in a bailout, I'll pick a Ford ANY day of the week. 


Oh, and for you lefty followers out there, yes, GM DOES STILL OWE BILLIONS TO THE GOV'T (TAXPAYERS)...

 

WHEN DO WE GET PAID BACK??????

 

THE TRUTH:  WE WILL LOSE.  The Treasury has already lost 1.6 BILLION (FACT) from the Chrysler bailout, GM's is "to be determined", we MAY learn the full "truth" about how much (estimates are around 12 BILLION).

 

Nice to know that the next 3 generations of kids will be paying for GM's cluster**ck accounting...

 

Yep, like the commercial says, "Chevy runs deep"...

 

Now if you all will excuse me, I've got to run to Walmart and get my Vaseline seeing I just did my taxes...

 

Just saying...

 

Sincerely,

 

A dis-satisfied customer and voter...

 

Apr 18, 2013 5:29PM
avatar
My choice...........FORD, FORD and FORD
Apr 18, 2013 7:08PM
avatar
I would NOT buy a vehicle from Government Motors after they screwed the country like they did, Imagine putting your retirement trust in GM before the country bailed them out. Their hierarchy & union are both crooked as the day is long. Ford worked their way out of trouble & bit the Bullitt to pull through on their own.
Apr 18, 2013 9:07PM
avatar
How can the American Public support GM after what they did to the shareholders and the country as a whole - i feel the same, if GM were head over heels better, would still go with FORD
Apr 19, 2013 1:20AM
avatar
I don't give a rats' rosey red rear about the stock market.  Ford has always given me great value.  I vote for ford.
Apr 18, 2013 11:23PM
avatar
And Ford didn't take Obama whore money!
Apr 18, 2013 5:43PM
avatar

Seeing MSN's other Money segment on Regal theatres being boycotted because of their ObamaCare decision - here's some reality for MSN Money - I DO NOT CARE IF GM WERE 100 TIMES BETTER THAN FORD....

 

I have not considered, nor will I EVER even consider a G(overnment) M(otors) vehicle again in my life - and this is from somebody who had previously purchased GM's from 1990 and up to Obama's takeover.  I will go out of my way to purchase a foreign car before I ever buy one.  That is reality.  Obama has done a great job of dividing us.  It's gonna take a lot more than words to united us.  MAYBE my kids will buy a GM someday, but NOT if I can help it.

Apr 18, 2013 6:15PM
avatar

" It's understandable why automakers are spending so heavily on ads these days: Put simply, business is good."

I beg to differ.  The deals most of these ads are touting sound like desperation.  The only reason sales are up is because so many years of flat or falling sales have left the public with a fleet of old vehicles that have to be replaced.  But we're still trying to squeeze a few more miles out of what we already have anyways, due to the poor economy still crimping our budgets.

 

You're confusing estimated sales with actual sales.  Or counting your chickens before they hatch.

Your inside-the-business analysis is mostly valid, but in the end profits come from actual sales.  Cutting costs tends to hurt quality, which in turn hurts reputation, which in turn hurts sales.  

 

Rely upon China's economy expanding?  Pretty risky.  China has been artificially propping up its own economy for decades and could collapse at any time.  Meanwhile they lack infrastructure and enough affluent buyers to afford to import cars from America.  Most of their population can't afford to buy a vehicle, even if they had decent roads to drive on and access to fuel.

 

Overall Ford offers a broader and more modern technology base.  Ford has more hybrid models than GM, and a pure electric.  Whether these cars hold up over time or not, Ford is demonstrating more technology leadership and investment than GM.  That positions them to hold better future potential.  Unless GM unveils a hidden gem (like Toyota did in the early 2000s with the Prius) it will continue to lag behind Ford (as well as several others).

 

Dang, and I used to be a GM man.

 

 

 

 

Apr 19, 2013 8:28AM
avatar
As a hard working American, and a long time GM shareholder, i ( we ) got the shaft -- NOTHING, for keeping my $ in the company, let them over indulge in everything, bonuses, perks and when it comes down to the end, my stock ( shares ) are valued at 0000.00. Not, now they come up with the Volt ?? and of course want me and everyone else to forget they ran this company in to the ground, yet they want us to support them again --- sorry
Apr 19, 2013 10:01AM
avatar
My last two Chevy's were junk, the seats weren't comfortable and so many little annoyances, and after the gummit screwed over the bondholders, I'll never buy a Chevy again.
Apr 18, 2013 7:01PM
avatar

I thought this was about the stocks....Not some of the Moron's choices in vechicles...??

You must be imbeciles because you can't READ...?

 

Own Ford stock, buy Chevys....There, fixed it for you..

 

Only "closet communist" by GM products...WTF is the matter with you,idiot.

We want GM to "pay back the rest" of the taxpayer funded loan/bailout...

How the hell do you think they do that?....Moron. 

Apr 18, 2013 9:26PM
avatar

GM WAS run poorly, they have completely turned it around. Even the CEO of Ford, Alan Mullaly, at the time lobbied for the bailouts, he was smart enough to know that had they not happened Ford would have went out of business too. Supply costs would have skyrocketed, and none of us would have been able to buy a car. Think about it, GM and Chrysler bailouts saved the entire auto industry.

 

Gm is a completely different company now, there cars, pickups and SUVs are good quality, and mpgs are getting better and better, as are Ford and Chrysler.

 

The American auto companies have come along way, and or sure are no longer 2nd fiddle to imports, all of the big 3 are good quality vehicles.

Apr 19, 2013 2:06PM
avatar

I've always been a chevy fan. But with GMAC being controlled by the same people who brought us Obama care.... I'll look at Ford/Dodge or anybody else before chevy.

Just wish the Ford will bring back the 7.3 L . BEST MOTOR EVER.

Apr 19, 2013 12:28PM
avatar
You forgot to mention that GM is a stolen compay They are here now only because they are thieves as they stole ownership from Grandmothers and Grandfathers  across the country, I ask Do you want to be part of that ????
avatar
As an American that believes that the entire concept of our nation revolves around blind equality, I will never be able to justify aiding any corporation that was given special status and absurd financial considerations that the rest of struggling business owners of this nation will never be given!  Ford forever, GM and Chrysler never!
Apr 19, 2013 7:09AM
avatar
i alawys love gm , but this has changed  too many problems an too many wires an relays on the engine now , so buy a ford this time , the gm workers made there true  face known we bailed them out an the cars an trucks have not changed nothing but throw away cars an trucks  its a job to them np pride in there work  caring more about family problems an was going on this weekend an that weekend  , so they do not care about how they put cars together an what parts they put on the cars good or bad , they always recall the cars an the engineneers dont care too.
Apr 19, 2013 2:44PM
avatar
Mitt Romney was right saying we should have let GM go into bankruptcy, what a way to shore up theirs pension plan...
Apr 18, 2013 10:47PM
avatar
Any of them as long as they don't give you a loan for more than you can pay back or afford.
Apr 19, 2013 3:14PM
avatar
Everyone who knows cars, knows the obama camp & the crappy news media is in the GM corner. If they ever let the public know What GM has been up to, people would not be happy. Example...GM is in the process of buying back its stock that the taxpayer bought. Guess what? They are buying back at a price lower than the taxpayer bought it for. I've heard @ a loss of 4 billion to we taxpayers!!! Let that sink in for a moment. Plus the money that GM is investing is mostly going to china. GM has 7 plants there now. Without a doubt Ford is a better car & truck. And a better company than GM.
Apr 19, 2013 3:31PM
avatar

I see only a handful of post relating to the topic of the article, the rest are personal stories on why they hate one brand over the other, with some political crap thrown in for good measure...

 

As an investor my money has and probably will be on Ford in the future for a number of reasons. Here's a few:(1) The Ford public brand image nowadays is generally looked upon favorably, and analysts seem to love Alan Mullaly and his execution. (2) Their product line has very little overlap, easier, more confident consumer experience and easier sale. (3) I also like their return on investment as well as cash stockpile. This tells me they are running lean and are set up for continual improvement in the long term..

 

Now back to Obama, bailouts, and your 83 Mustang II..

Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

DATA PROVIDERS

Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.

Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.

STOCK SCOUTER

StockScouter rates stocks from 1 to 10, with 10 being the best, using a system of advanced mathematics to determine a stock's expected risk and return. Ratings are displayed on a bell curve, meaning there will be fewer ratings of 1 and 10 and far more of 4 through 7.

113
113 rated 1
279
279 rated 2
416
416 rated 3
647
647 rated 4
548
548 rated 5
513
513 rated 6
669
669 rated 7
516
516 rated 8
317
317 rated 9
113
113 rated 10
12345678910

Top Picks

SYMBOLNAMERATING
KOGKODIAK OIL & GAS Corp10
UPLULTRA PETROLEUM Corp10
TAT&T Inc9
COPCONOCOPHILLIPS9
DVNDEVON ENERGY CORPORATION9
More

VIDEO ON MSN MONEY

ABOUT

Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.

Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.

Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.