Buffett quietly reshaping Berkshire
Passing on Transatlantic and buying into IBM signals a change in investment strategy.
Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B) rarely loses a deal fight, which makes Monday's news that the legendary investor was outbid for reinsurer Transatlantic Holdings (TRH) seem like a strange sight.
However, the fact that Berkshire lost out in a hotly contested bid to a competitor a nearly a tenth of its size in Alleghany Corporation (Y) should not be so surprising, given the Omaha, Neb., holding company's move away from its traditional reinsurance and insurance base and its shift to a more diversified portfolio of industrial companies.
With Berkshire's $9 billion acquisition of chemicals company Lubrizol earlier this year, adding to its $26.5 billion purchase of railroad Burlington Northern Santa Fe in 2009 and $4.5 billion acquisition of industrials conglomerate Marmon in 2007, the company has altered a quarter of its overall revenue and profit.
"This isn't an insurance company anymore, it's a defensive conglomerate," Tom Lewandowski, an analyst at Edward Jones, said about Berkshire's transformation through recent deals.
- 10 bank dividend stocks to be thankful for
- Boeing: You cut defense budget, we may close a plant
- JPMorgan may be safer play than Wells Fargo
While the billions spent on takeovers in recent years may look like a tack in strategy from minority investments and an insurance focus, Lewandowski says, "Berkshire has got where they are today because they haven't really changed a lot." Berkshire, as an investment management company, simply is sticking to its style of buying companies that need a giant funding source and have an attractive risk return, even if the nature of its investments are changing, Lewandowski says.
Overall, the company, which may soon generate $20 billion in annual cash from its operations, needs to put that money to work for its shareholders who've grown accustomed to seeing shares rise faster than the S&P 500 ($INX). Signaling the need to make new types of industrials takeovers and bank investments, the company's total insurance group's revenue and profitability is still below pre-crisis levels.
With quarterly cash stockpiles over $34 billion, Berkshires been able to spend billions in new types of investments as the global economic slump has turned many of America's blue chips into attractively priced, even distressed investments.
In 2008, Buffett played hero to the U.S. financial system by taking a $5 billion stake in Goldman Sachs (GS) and a $3 billion stake in General Electric (GE), allowing both companies to raise capital in the most tense moments of the financial crisis. This August, as uncertainty besieged Bank of America (BAC), the second largest bank in the U.S., Buffett made a similar investment. Recently, Berkshire's even entered into a new sector altogether with a $10.7 billion investment in IBM (IBM).
Even with new types of investments with an industrial and distressed focus, Berkshire's shares are lagging the S&P 500 in 2011, after outperforming the index for most of the company's history.
The question is whether plowing cash into industrial takeovers and an array of minority investments have been a boost to Berkshire share returns.
"I would say it's not been tremendously successful," says Meyer Shields an analyst with Stifel Financial about Berkshire's recent diversification. In doing its biggest ever deal by taking over Burlington Northern, Berkshire paid a 30% premium -- and it made a similarly pricey acquisition in Lubrizol at a $135 a share value. Recently, Berkshire's stake in IBM comes at a time when the IT giant's stock hovers near all-time highs above $175 a share.
Meanwhile, Berkshire's bank investments, while a boost to the global financial system, aren't guaranteed to provide a similar lift to its shareholders.
Currently, Berkshire's warrants in GE and Goldman Sachs are underwater and it has sold back preferred share stakes in the companies below market prices paid. Berkshire did see overall gains on the stakes because of stipulations in the stakes like fat dividends and premiums. With its Bank of America stake, Berkshire's returns are less certain. Currently its share purchase at $7.14 a share is well above current trading prices at below $5.16.
The new investment style, whether it's banks, tech or industrial company takeovers is not just about Berkshire putting its prolific cash to work in deals that only it can make. It's also about the small returns in its insurance business. "If there were profit opportunities similar to the likes of Lubrizol and Burlington Northern in insurance, then I'm sure he'd be happy to buy an insurance company," says Shields of Stifel. He adds, "The underlying profitability of the insurance business now is much weaker than it was years ago."
To boost shares, it's unclear whether Buffett's next move will be in continued bank shares, company takeovers or simple stock buybacks. In a recent Bloobmerg interview in Japan, where he was surveying the country's post-earthquake investing landscape, Buffett said, "On the Lubrizol transaction I think we spent about $8.7 billion. We'd love another one like that -- we can handle that. We can manage somewhat larger. We can handle a $10 billion deal very comfortably."
The setting in an earthquake ravaged country, along with a revival in investments amid the financial crisis begs the question of whether Berkshire may look at using its cash in uncharacteristic ways such as distressed investments. When pressed about what the Transatlantic deal said about Berkshire's investment style, Lewandowski of Edward Jones said that Berkshire's obstinacy in engaging in a bidding war or holding the insurance unit as a standalone entity illustrates how it's investing style hasn't changed over the years. About the types of investments Berkshire is willing to make, Lewandowski says, "I think that Buffett is generally indifferent." It's the style that doesn't change.
As that indifference has pushed Berkshire Hathaway into investing in distressed banks, industrial companies and, more recently, technology, it won't be a surprise if the legendary investor switches gears once again if debt-crisis stricken companies provide attractive new ways to spend cash.
If it wasn't for the bank bail outs that Buffet went to DC to lobby for himself there would not be a Berkshire Hathaway today. The derivative insurance payouts would have wiped out the company's assets and insurance investments..
As for paying 30% more for a railroad... Don't forget, he bought the WHOLE company. The unit trains for hauling coal 24 / 7 alone are cash cows. It was a great buy.
Buffett gets inside information that we as little people will never get. Also being big you get sweeter deals that us little people will never get a piece of.
Warren Buffett has proven over and over that his investment brilliance mark him as the Best & the Brightest investor ever. The rest of the mental"midgets" that pass themselves off as investment "experts" have shown that they would excell as cabdrivers, where they belong. He runs a co. that is valued in the billions with a dozen people, no limo's, no millions in salary's or
bonus's, none of the charade that characterizes Wall st.
God bless him, let's hope he lives a long and healthy life, many, many productive years.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
Shares of DVR pioneer TiVo are up 40% over the past 2 years, but unlike with the industry giants, there's still plenty of room to run with this pay-TV play.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.