Does a strong market mean a recovering economy?
MSN Money's Anthony Mirhaydari explains how new records on Wall Street may not add up to an improved financial landscape.
In the video below, MSN Money's Anthony Mirhaydari explains why, despite all the recent headlines about the stronger market, the overall economy may not be following suit.
On Oct. 9, 2007, the S&P 500 closed at 1,565.15. And it didn't brake that record until last Thursday -- when it finally closed about two points higher at its new, all-time high.
U.S. stocks fell apart in 2008 and 2009, as the U.S. economy has entered the Great Recession. Recovery has been slow going, and often amid concerns of double-dip recession. And financial woes haven't been limited to North America. Across the pond, Europe remains a mess and the U.K. is in its triple-dip recession.
So is the strengthening stock market an indication of a finally recovering economy? Not so fast, says Mirhaydari. Yes, the headline numbers sound great, but digging just a little bit underneath the surface reveals a much different picture.
Especially disturbing, Mirhaydari notes, is the situation in the U.S. labor market, where there is a still a job recession and much more is yet to be done.
The discussion about the strengthening market and the economy continues over at MSN Money's Facebook community.
More from Top Stocks
The market itself is just an illusion now, so, how can it possibly be an indicator of our economy?
What I’d like to know is how I’m supposed to run my magic show in Vegas when all the scoundrels on Wall Street have cornered the market in blue smoke and mirrors.
Wall street and the current economy is just one big April fool's joke!
What is really sad is by the end of the decade, the U.S. should/will be self-sufficient in the energy market and we will be exporting oil to other countries which in turn means that billion or even trillions of dollars will be flowing into this country.
Does that mean we will be fiscally responsible with all that money? No, I don't think so as we will continue to run up hugh deficits and Government will spend more of our money but the biggest crook of all is Big Business/Wall Street/Banks will demand bigger profits for the shareholders and will still continue to downsize the little people.
In the 1950's, we had 200 million Americans with 70 million of them working. Today, we have 320 million Americans with with 165 million working. How many more jobs can we create? Gone are the days where you stay at a company your whole career and get benefits. Now we have to pay for our own benefits.
We have to take back America from the greedy rich and big business but it will take all of us to do so. Buy a house to live in, and don't treat it as an investment. Stop buying new cars every other year. Start putting away money for the future. Stop trying to keep up with the Jones and take care of you and your family. You never deserve anything in life but you have to earn it.
"These small manufacturing data analysis means small market pullbacks that should be short lived."
says Financial Advisor Rank Amature of Brokerage house Dewey, Cheetum and Howe Capital LLC.
What we need is an inflation-adjusted measure of the stock market taking into the account the three fold increase in the money supply provided by the fed and spineless/brainless politicians who allowed it.
If you do this the market isn;t the market closer to 5,000?
The Markets seem to be where maybe they should be...?
Many Economic "trailing indicators are coming along.."
But there are also other indicators that show the Markets and many stocks are overbought..
IQ...........I've walked on Wall Street....I know where it is at.
Where dreams and fortunes are made and/or taken away..
Not like Wall St., in a town near us, where there are about 20 Trailers or Mobile homes.
IQ168....Maybe you meant to say..."The ' Economy ' and Wall St. are not same thing"??
Instead of: " the stock market has absolutely nothing to do with Wall St."
For some strange reason, I think they are pretty much the same thing...Just sayin'
"Especially disturbing, Mirhaydari notes, is the situation in the U.S. labor market, where there is a still a job recession and much more is yet to be done."
Eh. This is kind of misleading. Job market has been slowly getting better since 2009. A "recession" is characterized by negative growth, jobs don't fit that discription. So yes, unemployment is still too high. But big picture wise, it's gradually, slowly, getting better. (as part of the business cycle, not due to anything our idiot potus did). This means that earnings, on average, should gradually, slowly get better as well. The real question is, are all the earnings gains already factored in? or not?
Perhaps when the day finally comes that unemployment is low, Anthony will be telling we should buy stocks. Only problem is, unemployment historically trends in cycles, so really that will be when it's time to get out. (especially, considering the interest rate tsunami headed our way once the feds decide thier about face.)
I've said for at least 3-4 years that a strong market doesn't always relate to a strong economy.....
The Economy is the trailing indicator....And this recovery has been a snail sitting at the crossroads.
Today the DOW was flat..
The S&P back down under it's record close..
The Nasdq...down a little futher..
But the RUT was down almost 1.4%...
And several Stocks/Companies were down 1.5 -2+%...hmmmm.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
The idea of US crude being a shelter from turmoil abroad may not be as far fetched as it seems.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.