Can emerging markets take off in 2012?
BlackRock says fast-growing economies could decouple as the developed world struggles, but a global recession is still possible.
Do you feel lucky this year?
If so, you might want to bet on the optimistic side of the theoretical coin toss that the strategy team at BlackRock Investment Institute proposed in its investment outlook analysis, The Year of Living Divergently.
On the one hand, there's what BlackRock dubs the Nemesis scenario. It's kind of like an investment nuclear winter. Named after the Greek goddess who seeks revenge on those who are afflicted by the mortal sin of hubris, or excessive pride, it projects the ripple effects from a European financial meltdown spreading and setting off tsunami-type waves that swamp other national economies worldwide, including that of China.
The bad news in BlackRock's analysis: It wouldn't take a lot to trigger the Nemesis scenario -- a bank panic, perhaps, leading to the wholesale sell-off of risky assets; poor choices by policymakers; markets that respond to apparently sensible choices in unexpected ways; or the breakup of the eurozone.
Investors may take comfort from the Dow's relative strength so far this year. While there have been some days when the blue-chip indicator has ended in the red, it hasn't yet closed below the level where it ended 2011, and is up 3.6% so far. The same is true of the S&P, which has rewarded investors with a 4.7% advance thus far in 2012. That might be enough to convince investors (a) that the Nemesis scenario is one of those scary tales told around campfires at night, and (b) that it's OK to stay put right where they are. If you're feeling lucky, well, maybe that's a risk worth taking.
But the folks at BlackRock have a different outlook. They put the probability of Nemesis materializing at anywhere from 20% to 25% -- in which case there aren't very many places to shelter beyond the dollar, gold, and U.S., German and Japanese government bonds.
But they ascribe a higher probability to another worldview, one they dub "Divergence." In this scenario, there's a real and significant decoupling between the debt-laden economies of the developed world and outperformance by emerging markets. This opens up a whole panoply of investment options, from emerging markets stocks and bonds to energy and resource stocks and dividend-yielding securities in the developed markets.
It's an intriguing scenario, and one that is likely to meet with a reasonable degree of skepticism. After all, financial markets converged last year rather than diverging, to the pain and astonishment of investors who had been betting that emerging markets would reflect the relative resilience of the underlying economies. Indeed, the one investment call that left the most mud on the faces of the most advisors and pundits last year was probably the suggestion that clients should pile on the exposure to emerging markets. The premise was correct -- the economies of these nations did very well indeed, particularly on a relative basis -- but the markets didn't follow suit, thanks to massive risk aversion on the part of investors.
Is it going to be any different this year?
BlackRock argues that it will. Firstly, they note that policymakers in this part of the world have plenty of room to ease monetary policy. Here, the report appears prescient: Both Chinese and Indian policymakers have moved to do just that in recent weeks. Secondly, emerging markets assets are no longer overvalued on a relative basis after disappointing everyone so badly last year. Well, the valuations now speak for themselves.
What remains unclear is whether the third argument in favor of "it's different this time" will really prove to be accurate -- that emerging markets are becoming less risky. An even bigger question that BlackRock doesn't raise is whether investors will subscribe to this scenario in sufficient numbers and with sufficient conviction to have an impact on market values. The logic may be clear, but as financial markets have shown over and over again throughout the centuries, investors are anything but logical, particular in uncertain times.
Still, the report is worth keeping in mind at the end of a month that, despite some disappointing earnings news, has largely been a comfortable one for U.S. stock market investors. It serves as a reminder that the world outside remains a dangerous place, and that taking comfort in the U.S. stock market's relatively robust performance in January may be foolish short-term thinking.
At some point, BlackRock's pundits argue, we'll all have to decide which scenario we believe is more probable and act accordingly. It's an argument worth pondering, because the one certainty in any financial market scenario is that succumbing to complacency is the most dangerous path of all.
- 3 Plays That Can Boost Portfolios in 2012
- China Goes Nuts Over Pecans
- 10 Hot Investing Trends for 2012
I think I'll pass but thanks anyway team Blackrock!
Big Iconic Brand dividend paying stocks is where I'm staying for safety now!
At some point, BlackRock's pundits argue, we'll all have to decide which scenario we believe is more probable and act accordingly.Are you guys smoking wacky weed? Why does anyone have to choose anything relating to emerging markets? Keep your money invested in USA and Canadian Companies for the next few years!
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
The company plans to close stores and lay off employees, and says it needs to make some deeper changes.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.