Oil prices may rally on a US default
Ensuing actions by the Fed, such as another round of stimulus, could jolt commodity markets, analysts say.
By Andrea Tse, TheStreet
In either of those cases, "you're going to see the Fed react to that very swiftly and aggressively," says PFGBest senior energy analyst Phil Flynn.
"Initially everyone will freak out and say, 'Oh, my gosh, demand destruction'" in the world's No. 1 oil-consuming nation, then reverse their views upon another round of government stimulus or quantitative easing, which would bring an influx of hot, speculative money into the commodity markets, Flynn explains.
Summit Energy analyst Matt Smith agrees with Flynn to a lesser degree, saying that another round of quantitative easing would cause investors to immediately consider commodities as an inflation hedge, given that it would support dollar weakness and heighten inflation expectations. But "I think the view is tempered by the negative realities of quantitative easing."
To Smith, quantitative easing is a necessary evil -- a bandage -- rather than a long-term solution to the health of the general U.S. economy, which, of course, is required for strong oil demand.
Most analysts whom TheStreet spoke with agree that a U.S. credit downgrade is more likely to happen than an actual default because, as Mirus Futures chief market analyst Kurt Kinker explains, bringing down the overall level of U.S. debt "would require big cuts in spending. I don't think that's likely to happen. . . . It would be difficult for politicians to make the cuts."
A default, on the other hand, would likely be prevented. Most analysts believe that Democratic and Republican lawmakers will eventually reach a deal to raise the country's $14.3 trillion borrowing limit, even if it's after Aug. 2.
Flynn of PFGBest believes a downgrade would also be bullish for oil, encouraging an inflow of money away from U.S. debt and into higher-yielding emerging markets debt. Then they would invest the proceeds from their emerging-market investments in oil. Flynn said a good example of this is China's recent diversification away from U.S. debt and into European debt and commodities.
Smith agrees that a U.S. credit downgrade could spur diversification into oil but points out the longer-term ramifications of such a downgrade: a lack of confidence and therefore investment in the U.S., which could have a detrimental effect on the U.S. economy -- hence oil demand.
A U.S. default or credit downgrade may cause oil prices to rally or sink, depending on which facet and drivers of the oil markets the analyst focus on more. But Citi Futures Perspective energy analyst Tim Evans takes a look at another oil market driver possibility: deep spending cuts.
He says that even if there weren't a U.S. downgrade or default -- even if U.S. lawmakers on all sides came to an agreement on deep spending cuts that would bring down overall debt in the long-term -- oil prices could drop.
"I'm more concerned that U.S. (oil) demand will fall short of expectations. Cutting spending -- whether its government, business or consumers doing the cutting -- is a reduction in aggregate demand," Evans says. "Spending cuts would be a drag on the economy for years to come" with a serious risk that businesses won't pick up the spending slack from government cuts.
The United Kingdom, he said, is a good example of what he's worried about. "Britain adopted austerity measures a year ago, and they just posted a 0.2% GDP gain for Q2." Too much budget-balancing too soon could create a repeat of the 1937 U.S. recession, he said.
Kinker of Mirus Futures, meanwhile, believes the Federal Reserve is unlikely to implement another round of quantitative easing, given the widespread questions about the effectiveness of the previous rounds of stimulus programs, and will likely use a tool "that they never used before" to lift the economy.
As the Aug. 2 deadline for raising the U.S. debt ceiling approaches, "the pressure (on oil prices) will continue to ratchet up," said Smith of Summit Energy, noting that he expects to see a sell-off in crude under the influence of a general flight from risk if a compromise for raising the debt ceiling isn't reached -- though the move lower would likely be tempered by weakness in the dollar. Smith believes the next test to the downside would be $94 for West Texas Intermediate light sweet crude oil and around $110 for Brent crude oil.
Evans of Citi Futures Perspective said even without a default, spending cuts or economic slowing, the Brent market is overvalued by about $20 to $25 a barrel, so Brent could fall to $80 to $85 a barrel, similar to its drop in 2008, when a bearish economic scenario is added in.
Oil Price Information Service's chief oil analyst Tom Kloza said if the debt ceiling weren't an issue, he'd expect that oil prices would be headed for more modest levels in the August-to-September period, then begin a climb toward "the highest prices of our lifetime" as more investment and speculative money flows into oil between the fourth quarter of 2011 and first quarter of 2012 -- based a pattern that becomes more pronounced year after year -- and the Arab revolutions and emerging-market demand lift prices.
Oil and gas stocks were trying to recover after taking a hit Wednesday on U.S. debt ceiling concerns and mixed earnings reception.
Chesapeake Energy (CHK) was up 1.9% at $34.04, Range Resources (RRC) was gaining 2.5% to $65.82, and EOG Resources (EOG) was rebounding 1.2% to $105.32. Carrizo Oil & Gas (CRZO) was falling 1% to $38.33, and Occidental Petroleum (OXY) was sliding another 0.6% to $100.83. Forest Oil (FST) was adding 0.8% at $25.89, and Double Eagle Petroleum (DBLE) was rising 0.9% to $10.80.
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.