Facebook fiasco is disgraceful
In all my years on Wall Street, this is the most outrageous and egregious deal ever.
This Facebook (FB) fiasco is a disgrace.
The idea that big clients were getting the skinny that estimates were too high, something that would justify immediately cancelling orders or dumping stock into the public frenzy, is just plain outrageous. Anyone who made such a call knew that was selective disclosure, a clear violation of SEC rules. Anyone who acted on it has to be subpoenaed immediately by the SEC to find out what happened. The repercussions should and must be severe, as such a number cut on the eve of the deal is something everyone had to know -- not just the big boys.
Is there any wonder that there was such a vacuum after the deal started? Anyone who wasn't able to scale back on the number cut got a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to pick off the public at $42.
Heads, the insiders who were selling win; tails, they win. Heads, the big mutual fund clients who were selling win; tails, they win.
You got the chance to print money with that call.
More from TheStreet.com
Who knows where the deal should have really been done knowing that cut. I can tell you this $38 would have been ludicrous unless you really just wanted to blast the unsuspecting public as well as the Morgan Stanley retail network, which was overwhelmed with stock it didn't want at the last minute, perhaps because of the new selective disclosure.
Making matters worse, of course, is that the smaller investors who got stock would most likely be selling through the wholesalers like Knight, and it appears that the Nasdaq glitch specifically hurt the people who decided to get out of the deal on the pop. I know the right of the flipper to flip isn't the most hallowed, but the big boys got the $42 price directly. It was the little guy who was disenfranchised if he got stock and tried to sell.
Oh, and those who actually bought on the deal? We now know that many didn't even learn they owned it before the stock was well below the offering. Those were the Monday sellers with the really late reports.
All of this stinks, of course, but none of it stinks more than the idea that the Morgan Stanley analyst cut numbers at the last minute and only the largest clients were informed.
If that's really the case, then the SEC has to go to Morgan Stanley on Wednesday and get all telephone records, all transcripts, all correspondence and start sifting, because there's no way this didn't violate the rules.
In all my years on Wall Street, this is the most outrageous and egregious deal I have ever seen.
And now someone has to pay.
Jim Cramer is a co-founder of TheStreet and contributes daily market commentary to the financial news network's sites. Follow his trades for Action Alerts PLUS, which Cramer co-manages as a charitable trust, and has no positions in the stocks mentioned.
I think you have a little to be disgraced about here too.
You were like a cheerleader for the FB IPO on CNBC all day Thurs. and Fri. Morning. (along with the rest of the CNBC commentators)
Now you are on the Slam FB bandwagon. (along with the rest of the CNBC commentators)
Reminds me of watching Brent Mussberger (aka brent marshmellow) call a college football game.
JIMMY------DO YOU THINK WE ALL HAVE ALZHIEMERS
Agreed, Montands. CNBC was selling the HYPE, so people would tune in to their station to find out the latest hot nugget of information. Cramer is guilty of that also, but he, like the rest of us didn't have access to the last minute dissemination of valuable information. I do have to commend him speaking out, even if it is only to give his sorry bee-hind some shred of credibility and keep people watching his show.
The market is an insider game, and only the big players get the benefits.
Re-instate Glass-Steagall NOW!!!! Stop the insanity. The investment banks can not be allowed to steal from the public to make their bonus any longer!
I watched as MSN and other media outlets shamelessly hustled the IPO, more intensely as it drew near. "Buy FB, if you can even get it!!" Now they're running for cover and silly enough to think we can't remember what they said a week ago.
And yes, nothing changes with Wall Street or the banks. Same old story---the fix is in.
This is because Washington, D.C. and the politicians are owned by the financial system. They do a good job of finger wagging and scolding, but it is mostly a pretense with a wink and a nod. How many have actually been held accountable from the 2008 debacle? A couple sacrificial lambs?
This type of thing would not happen in 2012 after the economy was almost destroyed by the banks in 2008 unless there was complicity by the political system.
Oldest scam going. What does this company really do???? Bigger than McDonald more valuable than Coca Cola ??? People have to be real idiots to buy this junk.......it is junk stock worth less than $3.00
No track record...no assets.......all hype SCAM SCAM SCAM
THESE GUYS ARE LAUGHING ALL THE WAY TO THE BANK & THE PUBLIC TAKES IT IN
THE NECK AGAIN
Great, tell me something I didn’t know Friday by 6:00 p.m. just by looking at the FB trading price chart for the day. Here’s something more; Facebook insiders and senior managers were in on it from day one. And Goldman’s fund structure for distributing Facebook ownership to smaller investors is a scheme to circumvent SEC regulations. All of these folks should also be on your list of people who should now go to jail. This whole IPO was a shotgun blast of scams from beginning to end.
I hope my 401K managers did not buy any of this junk.
Sigh, but they probably did.
Even if the regulators get involved, so what. Unless somebody actually goes to jail, it's pretty much gonna be like this - "Ok Mr. Wall street criminal, you have stolen from the American people with impunity, you scoundrel. Now you know the rules..just give Congress their cut..er penalties and fines, we'll very publicly slap your naughty little hand..(and we'll both laugh all the way to the bank).." says the idignant congressman!
These Fraud street criminals don't even pretend it's gambling anymore, it's just a government sanctioned mugging of the peasant, er muppet..I mean middle class.
In my opinion, an overwhelming majority of those that make a living off day trading/gambling contribute nothing to the output of this nation. Nothing wrong with trying to make a few extra bucks on the side, and perhaps improve the retirement years, but good luck if you are trying to game the system. Once a week stocks decline on Euro worries, goes up for a day when housing sales improves; takes a dive for a few days on bad employment numbers, and so on and so forth. For the last 20 years the stock market has been much more about short term gains for large investors and less about long term stability and viability for companies and their ability to provide a stable outlook for the smaller investor. The shell game continues...
Copyright © 2014 Microsoft. All rights reserved.
Fundamental company data and historical chart data provided by Morningstar Inc. Real-time index quotes and delayed quotes supplied by Morningstar Inc. Quotes delayed by up to 15 minutes, except where indicated otherwise. Fund summary, fund performance and dividend data provided by Morningstar Inc. Analyst recommendations provided by Zacks Investment Research. StockScouter data provided by Verus Analytics. IPO data provided by Hoover's Inc. Index membership data provided by Morningstar Inc.
The solid report comes a month after the retailer closed all of its Canadian operations.
VIDEO ON MSN MONEY
Top Stocks provides analysis about the most noteworthy stocks in the market each day, combining some of the best content from around the MSN Money site and the rest of the Web.
Contributors include professional investors and journalists affiliated with MSN Money.
Follow us on Twitter @topstocksmsn.